Manny's Manifesto

​“I sound my barbaric yawp over the rooftops of the world.” ― Walt Whitman


I will only address a handful of the many errors, distortions, and lies in this highly fictionalized “Manifesto” authored by Emmanuel Hatzidakis. Every paragraph is misleading, every accusation false, and every conclusion schismatic. This manifesto instigates confusion among the faithful.

Illustrated PDF

mannys_manifesto_illustraded.pdf
File Size:	2776 kb
File Type:	pdf

Download File

---

​In the very first sentence, he says “people are not informed by the shepherds” in regards to the Holy and Great Council. This is categorically false. At every level of our church family we have direct communications and in-depth information. From our All Holy Patriarch, from our eminent Archbishop, our Metropolitans, from members who attended the Holy and Great Council, from Archons, and prominent theologians. Information via presentations at the national clergy-laity, local metropolis councils, and regional Archons have presented retreats on the subject. Books have been published, websites produced, online videos uploaded, encyclicals and sermons offered. This has been going on for well over a year and will continue into the foreseen future so we may all be “informed” and learn from the Council’s teaching.
 
He continues his tirade against the Holy and Great Council (June 2016 on the Island of Crete) which was presided over by His All Holiness and organized by all 14 autocephalous Churches, for several years. Yet he refers to it as the “so-called pseudo-Synod of Crete” …
 
His assertion “four Autocephalous Orthodox Churches did not participate in this pseudo-Synod of Crete, while two of these, the Churches of Bulgaria and Georgia, condemned its decisions”, somehow taints the authenticity of the council. This is a distortion.
Here are some facts:

• All 14 autocephalous churches worked on the documents, the council date, its location, and the agenda of the Holy and Great Council.
• In fact, the Antioch Patriarchate ‘boycotted’ the council due to an unresolved dispute with the patriarch of Jerusalem
• Bulgaria a very poor church could not justify the expenditure, initially, yet was later pressured not to attend even after Constantinople offered to underwrite the expenses
• Moscow pulled out two days prior to the convocation due to very petty reasons; literally, how the dais was organized. Even after the dais was fixed, Moscow changed her reason, and said arrangements could not be made in time… the day before. (The idiosyncrasies of Moscow’s stance are the makings of a Dan Brown novel and fodder for another response. In the end, the dignity of the Moscow Patriarch was diminished in my opinion)
• The Church of Georgia, did have an issue with one document and chose to refrain from the council, as opposed to being in attendance and voice their concerns and correct what they saw as error. In fact, some bishops made suggestions to documents that document and the alterations were made.
• All texts are available online: www.holycouncil.org

He says unequivocally “The worst is that our Patriarch and all the bishops that follow him want to unite with those other “Churches,” without first being united in the same faith.” This is a pure unadulterated lie. No Patriarch or bishop has ever suggested union until there is a return to Ortho-Doxa. A sober and precise study of the Orthodox position is available at www.assemblyofbishops.org (Ministries/Inter-Christian Tab)
In an audacious statement “According to our Patriarch, the differences that exist between us, which the Holy Synods of the Church have condemned, do not prevent us anymore from uniting.” As I indicated earlier this is a complete false accusation. A debased lie which impugns the dignity of the ongoing Orthodox-Catholic dialogues. Accurate information on this subject is available www.patriarchate.org
More of his “manifesto” nonsense;

• They [American Bishops] fiercely hunt down priests who dare to baptize converts.
• They allow marriages with non-Orthodox, without requiring them to become Orthodox.

Its seems elementary that these claims can be explained by the youngest of Sunday School children. In a final spasm of degeneration Fr Emmanuel claims “The faith of our Fathers is not followed by our Patriarch and by all the bishops in America”. I outright condemn this statement and ask you do t the same
He concludes his ‘manifesto” with schismatic endorsements and dangerous conclusions and advice which should be plainly rejected and rebuffed:
·         Courageously resist our ecumenist Bishops
·         Priests who want to remain Orthodox need to stop commemorating them during the Divine Liturgy (Schism)
·         Start following an Orthodox Bishop (not a Greek Archdiocese Bishop)
 
The sheer audacity of Fr Emmanuel Hatzidakis’s self-aggrandizement to have his son distribute this vitriol and manifesto of lies to Orthodox faithful during the Holy Procession of Icons on the Sunday of Orthodoxy this past weekend (March 5, 2017) must be admonished. To cause division and scandal among the faithful is one thing, difficult to comprehend, but to outright lie and distort Truth while doing so deserves a strong rebuke.
Manny’s manifesto is a tawdry tale of fiction and deception. Avoid it and its ilk.